Helping 10,000+ drivers find non-owner car insurance agents nationwide

Nickel City Insurance Agency

4.5(46 reviews)

5775 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086

Independent Agency

NoCar Plan hasn't verified non-owner or SR-22 coverage for this agent. See other agents in Lancaster or call to ask directly.

Opens tomorrow at 9 AM

Call NowGet DirectionsVisit Website

About

Nickel City Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency in Lancaster, New York. Contact them at +1 716-683-2130 to ask about non-owner car insurance and other coverage options.

Business Hours

Closed
monday9 AM – 4 PM
tuesday9 AM – 4 PM
wednesday9 AM – 4 PM
thursday9 AM – 4 PM
friday9 AM – 4 PM
saturdayClosed
sundayClosed

Location

View on Google Maps

Been to Nickel City Insurance Agency?

Help others with a quick 10-second report. No account needed.

Did they offer non-owner car insurance?

Did they handle SR-22 filing?

Overall experience?

Anything else? (optional)

Plain-English primer

Should You Switch to Non-Owner Car Insurance?

If you've sold a car, moved to a transit city, or consolidated vehicles, you might be ready to switch from full-coverage to non-owner insurance. Here's how to run the math and do it without a lapse.

Compare Non-Owner Insurance Quotes Online

Get quotes from multiple carriers in minutes — no phone calls required.

Get a Quote

Other Agents in Lancaster

Robert E Schaff LTD Insurance & Real Estate

5(31)

33 Central Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086

View Profile

Charles Snyder: Allstate Insurance

4.8(121)

3725 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086

Non-Owner
View Profile

Shannon McNichol: Allstate Insurance

5775 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086

Non-Owner
View Profile
See all agents in Lancaster