Helping 10,000+ drivers find non-owner car insurance agents nationwide

Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.)

4.9(370 reviews)

878 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

Is this your agency? This page works harder when you own it →

Independent Agency

NoCar Plan hasn't verified non-owner or SR-22 coverage for this agent. See other agents in Shirley or call to ask directly.

Opens Monday at 9 AM

Call NowGet DirectionsVisit Website

About

Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.) is an independent insurance agency in Shirley, New York. Contact them at +1 631-395-1000 to ask about non-owner car insurance and other coverage options.

Business Hours

Open Now
monday9 AM – 6 PM
tuesday9 AM – 6 PM
wednesday9 AM – 6 PM
thursday9 AM – 6 PM
friday9 AM – 6 PM
saturdayClosed
sundayClosed

Location

View on Google Maps

Been to Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.)?

Help others with a quick 10-second report. No account needed.

Did they offer non-owner car insurance?

Did they handle SR-22 filing?

Overall experience?

Anything else? (optional)

Is this your page?

Drivers in Shirley find this listing when they search. Own it: verified badge, instant edits, and top placement in Shirley — everything for $29/mo.

Claim this page

Plain-English primer

Should You Switch to Non-Owner Car Insurance?

If you've sold a car, moved to a transit city, or consolidated vehicles, you might be ready to switch from full-coverage to non-owner insurance. Here's how to run the math and do it without a lapse.

Compare Non-Owner Insurance Quotes Online

Get quotes from multiple carriers in minutes — no phone calls required.

Get a Quote

Other Agents in Shirley

Lighthouse Insurance Shirley

4.6(204)

960-B Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967

View Profile
See all agents in Shirley